“Accidental Racist” Does More Harm Than Good

Entertainment has the potential to carry potent messages.  Politically-minded entertainers can use their mediums to give us pause and force us to question how we think about and live in the world.   For example, I can think of songs (“Fight the Power” and A Change is Gonna Come ), films (Higher Learning, American History X, Bamboozled, and Crash), books (Beloved and The Color Purple), and art (Augusta Savage and Faith Ringgold) that all changed how I thought about race in America.

The new song, “Accidental Racist,” by Brad Paisley and LL Cool J will never make this list. In this ditty, Paisley defends, among other things, symbols of Southern pride (e.g., the Confederate flag) crooning, “We’re still pickin’ up the pieces, walkin’ on eggshells, fightin’ over yesterday/And caught between southern pride and southern blame.” Not to be outdone, LL Cool J responds with the following: “If you don’t judge my do-rag/I won’t judge your red flag/If you don’t judge my gold chains/I’ll forget the iron chains.”

Not surprisingly, the artists have taken a lot of heat this week. The song  has taken a beating by TV hosts (for example, Toure on MSNBC), and music critics alike (See the review by Chicago Sum-Times critic Richard Roeper who calls it “accidental garbage” as well as  Billboard Magazine’s  unflattering article titled, “Brad Paisley’s ‘Accidental Racist’: LL Cool J’s Craziest Lyrics”).  Both artists defend the intention of the song.  LL Cool Jay told Jay Leno that “The song wasn’t perfect. You can’t fit 300 or 400 years of history into a three or four minute song.” He added that “I would never, ever suggest to anyone that we should just forget slavery and act like that didn’t happen. I understand the systemic racism that exists, I get that, but you know what? If the playing field is unlevel and you feel it’s unfair, then maybe putting down some of that baggage will make getting up that hill a little easier.”

Paisley echoed this sentiment In an interview with Entertainment Weekly. He noted:

“I think that [the song] comes from an honest place in both cases, and that’s why it’s on there and why I’m so proud of it. This isn’t a stunt. This isn’t something that I just came up with just to be sort of shocking or anything like that. I knew it would be, but I’m sort of doing it in spite of that, really…. I just think art has a responsibility to lead the way, and I don’t know the answers, but I feel like asking the question is the first step, and we’re asking the question in a big way. How do I show my Southern pride? What is offensive to you? And he kind of replies, and his summation is really that whole let’s bygones be bygones and ‘If you don’t judge my do rag, I won’t judge your red flag.’ We don’t solve anything, but it’s two guys that believe in who they are and where they’re from very honestly having a conversation and trying to reconcile… But, you know, it’s such a complicated issue — I’m reading up on it now, [since] I felt I needed to be well-armed for any discussion – and here he is in a Yankees cap, and you think to yourself, ‘Well here is the antithesis of what was the problem.’ But it’s not. New York City was all for slavery. They actually voted 60 percent against — or maybe 70 against — Abraham Lincoln because they didn’t like the idea of slavery going away because there goes cotton and there goes tobacco trade, you know what I mean? It’s very hypocritical to feel like it’s just the South’s fault.

Paisley insists that he wanted to start a much needed national conversation. Assuming this is true, I am not sure I want to engage in a conversation based on completely naïve assumptions about the “race problem” or how to address racial inequality in America. I am sure that institutional racism, for example, could be easy be addressed if only we looked past how one was dressed.     

Snarky comments aside, “Accidental Racist” does little to promote meaningful discourse or challenge status quo. Superficial art about race simply props racism (and its symbols) up. MK Asante, commenting in NYT’s Room for Debate said it best. “Racism is a lot of things — cancerous, insidious, learned, dangerous, destructive, dumb, vicious, institutional — but not accidental.”Image


About Double take Sociology

I am a Professor of Sociology, a Research Associate in the Pepper Institute on Aging and Public Policy, and an Associate Dean for Faculty Development and Community Engagement in the College of Social Sciences and Public Policy at Florida State University. I research (and write about) social movements, mass media and politics. To find links to my research, visit www.DeanaRohlinger.com.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to “Accidental Racist” Does More Harm Than Good

  1. Kevin Stepp says:

    My classes examined the lyrics to this song last week. The most pointed comment was from a senior who, in the midst of a lively discussion that ranged from advocating “putting the Stars and Bars away” as the Germans have done with the swastika to declarations that we (teenagers) are “post-racial”, citing the ascension of such powerful figures as Oprah, Jay-Z, and President Obama, asked if Paisley’s point wasn’t really aimed at those people who are theorizing about race issues, but at those who are living with such person-to-person moments as a Skynyrd shirt at a Starbucks.
    People who had heard it (I haven’t) thought the song was weak, even absent the lyrics.

  2. I agree. The music wasn’t written for scholars and the person-to-person moments matter. The struggle with history and identity is real. I think that if the song had really tapped into these issues the artists wouldn’t have been lambasted as they were. Generally speaking, I do not expect much from entertainers. They are simply marketing themselves for a living. Once they get political, however, all bets are off. If you cannot move beyond the what one wears, you should probably avoid the topic.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s